Introduction. The Colca Valley (CV) in Arequipa, Peru hosts farming communities whose water has been systematically extracted since 1983 by the Majes-Siguas Special Project (PEMS-I) to irrigate coastal agriculture. Four decades later, upstream communities face severe scarcity, deteriorated infrastructure, and minimal State investment. With PEMS-II under construction to irrigate 38,000 additional hectares, cumulative impacts on governance, livelihoods, and cultural practices remain undocumented. Objective. To characterize structural water insecurity in CV communities and its effects on water governance, agricultural livelihoods, and traditional water culture. Methods. Qualitative study combining 38 indepth interviews with farmers, water distributors, ritual practitioners, and water authorities; 20 participatory diagnostic workshops with CV Water Users Board commissions; and ethnographic observation. Data were triangulated with in-stitutional records and thematically analyzed through a political ecology framework. Results. Five findings: (1) Chronic investment inequity: Decades of sustained State investment in PEMS-I and ongoing PEMS-II contrast sharply with the minimal, discontinuous investment in highland irrigation infrastructure, systematically privileging coastal water use. Communities along the PEMS canal secured partial access only through sustained collective struggle, yet face seasonal disruptions; those outside it depend on declining springs under far more precarious conditions. (2) Institutional fragility: outdated and insufficient water-use licenses (2007) and limited knowledge of national water legislation. (3) Food system transformation: water scarcity and market pressures are driving changes toward cash crops and agrochemicals, weakening livestock systems and eroding agrobiodiversity. (4) Compounded vulnerability: one community faces unremediated mining tailings rendering farmland unproductive, while active informal mining threatens its only drinking-water source. (5) Cultural resilience: despite State neglect, communities sustain communal water distribution, collective canal cleaning, and water rituals, though intergenerational transmission erodes as youth migrate. Conclusions. Four decades of extraction have exacerbated inequity and are transforming food systems and threatened cultural continuity Redressing investment gaps, recognizing communal governance, and securing upstream rights are essential as PEMS-II advances.